Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s tweet last week that he was considering taking the company private raises the question: Do public markets, with the huge amount of capital they provide to new mobility companies, hurt or help those operations?

The stock markets detract from the day-to-day work at Tesla, Musk admitted. “This is all about creating the environment for Tesla to operate best,” he wrote in an email to employees that was later posted on the company’s blog. “As a public company, we are subject to wild swings in our stock price that can be a major distraction for everyone working at Tesla.”

At first glance, Musk’s dissatisfaction with public markets that have been extremely kind to Tesla seems surprising. With a market valuation that has grown to rival and sometimes surpass much bigger automakers whose production volume and profits eclipse its own, Tesla has benefited enormously from Musk’s ability to inspire public market investors.

Musk: Master of market hype Photo credit: REUTERS

But Bloomberg reported last week that a Securities and Exchange Commission inquiry into Tesla is not just about whether Musk should have used Twitter to announce the going-private proposition. It also seeks “general information about Tesla’s public pronouncements on manufacturing goals and sales targets,” signaling that Musk’s mastery of stock market hype may have gone too far.

Once a vision of the future has been sold to markets, it can take on a life of its own. The stock market doesn’t have the patience to weather the inevitable ups and downs that come with disruptive technologies, particularly from companies such as Tesla that are trying to upend the highly cyclical auto industry while relying on regular capital infusions to stay afloat. The dual risks of markets losing confidence in Musk’s ability to deliver on his daring goals and a broader macroeconomic downturn — the “force majeure” that Musk may have been alluding to in Tesla’s second-quarter earnings call — could be inspiring Tesla’s flight to the relative safety of private ownership.

To established automakers, Musk’s predicament likely comes across as overdue karmic retribution. The industry has struggled to inspire the optimism that Musk has built around Tesla. But they are steeped in the art of surviving the lean years of regular economic downturns. If investors are indeed re-evaluating the potential of companies such as Tesla to significantly impact the car business, execs at established companies may be finding their frustration turning to relief.

They may not have maximized their share prices during one of the strongest bull markets in recent memory, but they face less of a fall from grace.

{{title}}

{{abstract}}
Read more >